August 5, 2020


By: The Humane Society of Greater Dayton

Left in the cold. Filthy, disgusting mud halfway up their legs. Shivering in single digit temperatures. Squealing for help. That is how our humane agent found seven pigs on cold January day, including one piglet we named Ayesha. 

During an investigation, our humane agent visited a property owned by two brothers who had had troubled caring for animals for decades, the Humane Society of Greater Dayton’s humane agent heard distressed animal noises coming from up a driveway that ran adjacent to the property. Upon walking up the driveway, she discovered a pen of pigs in extremely poor conditions. They were standing in a combination of bone-chilling mud, urine and fecal matter with nowhere to escape. The water was just 46 degrees. 

The humane agent spoke with the owners, who do not reside at the property, and informed them to fix the living situation as well as provide proper food and water for these animals. They agreed to do so in the allotted time given. Upon returning multiple times, nothing had changed. The animals were still in the liquid mud and visibly shivering. The teeth of the piglets were chattering so loudly you could hear them. 

A winter storm was quickly approaching, and our humane agent saw the urgency in removing these animals to save their lives. Without stepping in quickly, she knew the animals would not survive the storm. 

Our humane agent removed the seven pigs and piglets from the horrible situation. It was after midnight by the time transport arrived and the temperatures were below zero but, at last, the animals were finally dry, safe and warm. 

Ayesha and the other pigs were visibly shivering, dehydrated and suffering from mange, malnutrition and urine burns. Despite continued warnings, the two brothers had done nothing to improve the living conditions for these animals. 

After removing them, the brothers accused our humane agent of improperly removing the animals without a sufficient search warrant. Despite their efforts, a 2nd District Court of Appeals Judge ruled in favor of the State of Ohio and Humane Society of Greater Dayton, setting a new precedent in the State of Ohio for livestock. With this ruling, animals may be seized from a property under the Open Field Doctrine. This basically means that if law enforcements views an animal in a neglected or abused state on any property the animal can be immediately seized from the conditions with no search warrant needed. 

After more than a year of litigation, the two brothers were both also found guilty of four counts each of animal cruelty. They are prohibited from keeping pigs and other animals (with the exception of a few pets that were not being neglected) They will face inspections for five years and may go to jail for 90 days for any violation. They must also pay $13,000 each to the Humane Society of Greater Dayton for the care and rehabilitation of these seven pigs while the case was pending. Since the ruling, our humane agent had to sadly remove a horse from the property due to neglect and unsafe living conditions. Luckily though, all of these animals are now thriving and are now all free from suffering in their new forever homes. 

Media Inquiries

For media inquiries, photos or information regarding these stories, contact

You May Also Like
July 22, 2019

Safely Take a Dip During the Dog Days of Summer

What better way to cool off these dog days of summer than with a dip in the pool? On a hot day, your dog may agree that the pool is […]

August 1, 2019

UPDATE: 20 Cats in Just 24 Hours

UPDATE: Two weeks ago, the Humane Society of Greater Dayton had to temporarily close all intake and adoptions of cats at our main facility following 20 cats that were abandoned […]

August 2, 2014

Keep Your Dogs Safe in Pools

What better way to cool off this summer than with a dip in the pool? On a hot day, your dog may agree that the pool is the best activity […]